Category موضوعي
Evidence and research methods
Reading evidence, comparing interpretations and assessing the limits of inference.
Advanced search →Artifact 9 Entity 197 Period 2 Person 52 Site 17 Study 82 Ancient text 10
-
Illustration
Entity
Demonology
Study or organization of harmful powers, names, origins and roles within specific traditions; no single doctrine or claim about existence beyond the text is assumed.
Modern functional comparison of different witnesses, not a fixed chronology or historical portrait. A council role alone does not date Job
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Asael / Azazel
Name forms in Enochic tradition associated with corrupting teaching and punishment; witness variation cautions against one fixed form and identity everywhere.
Modern comparison of Enoch 8/10, Jubilees 10 and 1QM 13. Not one figure’s transformation. Jubilees 10:11 uses Satan in Mastema’s context; local overlap is not denied
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Belial
Figure associated with darkness and wickedness in some Qumran texts; not a fixed alias for every heavenly adversary.
Modern comparison of Enoch 8/10, Jubilees 10 and 1QM 13. Not one figure’s transformation. Jubilees 10:11 uses Satan in Mastema’s context; local overlap is not denied
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Mastema
Leader of harmful spirits in Jubilees; requests some spirits and proposes Abraham’s test, subject to divine limits.
Modern comparison of Enoch 8/10, Jubilees 10 and 1QM 13. Not one figure’s transformation. Jubilees 10:11 uses Satan in Mastema’s context; local overlap is not denied
Read the record → -
Illustration
Study
From gods to angels
From Ugarit’s council to heavenly beings in Kings, Job, Daniel, Tobit and Enoch: continuity of structures, roles and names, and the limits of proving an individual god became an angel.
Modern analytical diagram separating structure, role and identity. Comparative questions, not an archaeological chain proving a god became an angel
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Seraphim
Six-winged beings in Isaiah 6’s throne vision, associated with praise and purification; not automatically identical to cherubim or every angel.
Modern paraphrase of Genesis 3/32, Exodus 25 and Isaiah 6. Not a historical depiction of the beings or a fixed taxonomy for all Judaism
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Cherubim
Beings or figures with guarding and sacred functions in Hebrew texts, at the tree-of-life access and on the ark; not equivalent to every heavenly messenger.
Modern paraphrase of Genesis 3/32, Exodus 25 and Isaiah 6. Not a historical depiction of the beings or a fixed taxonomy for all Judaism
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Watchers
Designation for heavenly beings in Daniel and Enochic literature, covering an obedient holy watcher or a rebellious group according to context.
Modern comparison of Daniel 4 and 1 Enoch 6–15: a watcher is not necessarily fallen, and giant spirits are not simply watchers renamed. Row order does not date composition
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Angelology
Study and organization of angels and heavenly beings: names, ranks and roles within particular traditions, without assuming one fixed system.
Modern analytical diagram separating structure, role and identity. Comparative questions, not an archaeological chain proving a god became an angel
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Study
From a national god to the god of the universe
Exclusive allegiance and denial of other gods: inscriptions, Assyrian/Babylonian crises and Second Isaiah, separating events from composition and disagreements over monotheism.
Cyrus Cylinder, Babylon, after 539 BCE; British Museum 90920. Actual artifact; inscription does not name Yahweh
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Second Isaiah
Scholarly label for Isaiah 40–55, substantially linked to exile and Cyrus; not proof of one author or one year for every verse.
Modern editorial paraphrase of three Isaiah passages, not a manuscript or full translation. Wording is attested; historical meaning and layered dating remain research questions
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Babylonian exile
Judean deportations to Babylonia and the kingdom’s collapse in the early sixth century BCE; several phases, not everyone removed or returned at once.
Modern diagram of political reference points. It does not date monotheism’s birth or imply everyone’s simultaneous deportation/return
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Henotheism
Privileging one god while acknowledging others in the working definition used here; not automatically monotheism or a fixed social phase.
Modern comparison of working definitions. Terms overlap and vary across scholars; arrangement does not date three successive stages for everyone
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Monolatry
Worship of one deity without necessarily denying others; variable analytical term, not one uniform doctrine of all Israelites.
Modern comparison of working definitions. Terms overlap and vary across scholars; arrangement does not date three successive stages for everyone
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Study
Yahweh and Asherah
Blessings at Kuntillet ʿAjrud and el-Qom, female figurines and reform narratives: separating evidence from interpretation while examining worship before Yahweh’s exclusivity.
Female pillar figurine from Lachish, ceramic, about eighth–seventh century BCE; Metropolitan Museum 34.126.53, height 18.4 cm. Actual artifact; attribution to Asherah is unresolved
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Asherah cult symbol
Asherah as a cult object or symbol, often wooden in biblical contexts; relation to the goddess and inscriptional ʾšrth remains debated.
Modern distinction between goddess, ritual term and inscription reading. No invented excavated wooden pole; symbol and goddess not always mutually exclusive
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Concept
Judean pillar figurines
Clay female figurines with pillar bases in Judah, especially widespread in the eighth/seventh centuries BCE; identity and function not determined by form alone.
Female pillar figurine from Lachish, ceramic, about eighth–seventh century BCE; Metropolitan Museum 34.126.53, height 18.4 cm. Actual artifact; attribution to Asherah is unresolved
Read the record → -
Illustration
Site
Khirbet el-Qom
Site west of Hebron known for an eighth-century BCE funerary inscription commonly associating Yahweh with “his asherah”; damaged text and readings disputed.
Modern diagram of context, common reading and limits at el-Qom. Not the inscription or its physical layout; debated translation not made certain
Read the record → -
Illustration
Site
Kuntillet ʿAjrud
Sinai site preserving blessings by Yahweh of Samaria/Teman and “his asherah” around 800 BCE; building function and wording disputed.
Modern summary of two Kuntillet ʿAjrud formulas in published readings. Not a jar photograph, inscription facsimile or map; does not settle “his asherah” or drawing identities
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Study
Ugarit
From the 1929 excavations and alphabetic cuneiform to houses, scribes and the Baal Cycle: what does Ugarit reveal about Levantine gods, and where are the limits of comparison?
Entrance to Ugarit at Ras Shamra, near Latakia; M. Benoist, August 1989. Modern photograph of the remains, not an ancient-city reconstruction
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Dagan
Deity known in Syria and Mesopotamia, attested in Ugaritic lists, offerings and names; Baal is called his son. Temple attribution remains debated.
Modern comparison of Ugaritic evidence for Dagan; not a divine likeness or a settled identification of the temple
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Urtenu and his house
Ugaritic figure close to court and commerce, associated with a south-central archive; family and personal texts helped identify its owner.
Modern grouping of evidence types from Urtenu’s house in the selected 1995 pages; not a room plan or complete archive census
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Ilimilku
Ugaritic scribe associated with the Baal Cycle, Kirta and Aqhat; handwriting and colophons aid attribution. His work alone does not date the traditions’ origins.
Modern distinction between Ilimilku’s scribal work and the origin of recorded traditions; no portrait or claim that he invented the myths
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Concept
Ugaritic alphabet
Long cuneiform alphabet of 30 signs, chiefly consonantal. Its wedge shapes do not imply Akkadian syllabic principles or priority as the first alphabet.
Incomplete Ugaritic abecedary, Louvre AO 19992 / RS 10.087, museum date about 1400–1200 BCE; found 1938, 7 letters missing. Not the complete RS 12.033 found 1948
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Study
El and Baal
The old father and the young god: battle, palace, mourning, Athtar’s throne and Shapshu’s warning reveal overlapping authority without a narrative of El’s deposition.
Baal with Thunderbolt stela from Ugarit, limestone, Louvre AO 15775 / RS 4.427. The museum assigns a broad date of 2000–1150 BCE. This depicts Baal, not El, and does not prove that Baal overthrew him
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Kothar-wa-Hasis
Craftsman god in the Baal Cycle, supplying weapons and building the palace.
Modern explanation of the craftsman’s battle and building roles; no reconstruction of the weapons or palace
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Athtar
God who tries Baal’s throne on Saphon during his absence, then descends; it is not El’s throne.
Modern diagram of KTU1.6I; Athtar is not presented as a fallen angel or denied all kingship beyond Saphon
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Shapshu
Ugaritic sun goddess; involved in Baal’s crisis and intervening verbally in the Mot conflict.
Modern explanation of Shapshu’s roles in the passages consulted; her warning does not mean El actually deposed Mot in the scene
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Mot
God of death in the Baal Cycle; an adversary who returns even after a violent attack.
Modern diagram of three points in Mot’s story; no proof of an annual agricultural rite or a complete revival mechanism
Read the record → -
Illustration
Entity
Yam / Nahar
Sea god and Baal’s opponent for kingship, also associated with Nahar, River.
Modern narrative diagram of Baal and Yam; no likeness of the Sea god or reconstruction of the cycle’s lost opening
Read the record → -
Illustration
Study
Did El Have an Image?
Between the tentatively identified seated figurine and the elder described in texts: separating artifact attribution from literary appearance, and comparing El with the Ancient of Days without inventing a transmission route.
Modern diagram distinguishing the object, its attribution and El’s textual portrayal. It neither depicts El nor settles the statue’s identity
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Marziḥu
A banqueting institution or association in Ugaritic documents, with religious functions not reducible to one ritual.
Modern diagram of evidence relevant to the marziḥu; no reconstruction of El’s feast, guest count or ritual
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
KTU: Ugaritic Text References
Abbreviation for a modern scholarly corpus of alphabetic cuneiform texts; its numbers are references, not dates.
Modern reference guide: KTU1.114 corresponds to RS24.258 in Spronk’s chapter. No ancient writing or tablet surface reproduced
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Ancient of Days
Designation of the divine figure with white hair, throne and court in Daniel7.
Modern textual comparison, depicting neither El nor the Ancient of Days and proving no direct transmission route
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Aniconism
Avoidance of divine images in a particular practice or tradition; not inferred solely from an unidentified artifact.
Modern diagram of different explanations for an unidentified image; not evidence that any one occurred at Ugarit
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Concept
Iconography
Study of images, their attributes and contexts; resemblance alone does not prove identity.
Seated god, possibly El; Ugarit, 1400–1300 BCE according to the catalogue; gold-covered bronze, RS 23.394 / S3573. Catalogue information names Damascus Museum in 2011; current whereabouts not verified here. Attribution to El remains tentative
Read the record → -
Original photograph
Study
Who Headed the Sumerian Divine Assembly? An or Enlil?
From Fara lists to Lugalzagesi’s inscription and Ekur: An’s seniority, Enlil’s authority and why list order cannot establish a transfer of the throne.
Ziggurat mound at Nippur from the southwest, photograph by Noémi Alzayadi. The building on top dates to late-nineteenth-century excavations, not a standing Sumerian temple. Modern site context; display copy resized only
Read the record → -
Illustration
Study
The Earliest Divine Names in Mesopotamia: When Writing Preserved the Name
From Uruk tablets to Fara lists: Nanna, Ninlil, Inanna, Enlil and An, and what makes a divine name readable without equating first attestation with the beginning of worship.
Modern distinction between logogram, phonetic use and determinative. Functions overlap; no ancient signs or fixed universal stages reproduced
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Logogram
A sign representing a word or related words; context selects the reading, and a sign may also have phonetic uses.
Modern distinction between logogram, phonetic use and determinative. Functions overlap; no ancient signs or fixed universal stages reproduced
Read the record → -
Illustration
Concept
Divine determinative
A usually unspoken sign classifying a name as divine; usage differs by language, period and name.
Modern distinction between logogram, phonetic use and determinative. Functions overlap; no ancient signs or fixed universal stages reproduced
Read the record →